Open Thread – Thursday 5 August 2021

This entry was posted in Open Forum. Bookmark the permalink.

5,078 Responses to Open Thread – Thursday 5 August 2021

  1. Whalehunt Fun says:

    I comment is up. That is what


    Report comment
  2. K2 says:

    West Coast Eagles are shit pea-hearted xunts……. Fremantle have a brighter future; supposing there is a future.


    Report comment
  3. srr says:

    ConservativeChicky @ConservativeChicky 1h
    https://gab.com/ConservativeChicky/posts/106698076085757680

    Fast-spreading COVID variant can elude immune responses
    https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-00121-z
    21 Jan 2021

    This is now straight out Emperor’s New Clothes.
    NO Symptoms, CAN’T test for it, oh but PANIC!!


    Report comment
  4. Alpha Romeo says:

    No matter how bad Julie Bishop turned eventually out to be.

    Her arms really weren’t all that bad…

    I’ll say that for her.


    Report comment
  5. srr says:

    ‘Outrageous’: Dan Andrews slammed
    4:34PM
    Daniel Andrews’ government has been labelled as ‘corrupt’ in parliament over a polling scandal involving the use of taxpayers’ money.

    https://www.news.com.au/national/victoria/politics/victorian-opposition-slams-daniel-andrews-government-over-corrupt-taxpayer-spend/news-story/45fa662b6fe887071b6fbc8978b8991a

    I don’t know, it just seems odd to read this in “Breaking News”.


    Report comment
  6. rocinante says:

    Thanks for your efforts, Tom.


    Report comment
  7. jupes says:

    FFS Adam. Get rid of this dickhead before he get’s rid of the site.


    Report comment
  8. Mak Siccar says:

    In today’s Oz.

    Closing the Gap: Stolen children to be given $378m redress

    PAIGE TAYLOR
    INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS CORRESPONDENT, WA BUREAU CHIEF

    GREG BROWN
    JOURNALIST

    AUGUST 5, 2021

    Thousands of Indigenous Australians who were removed from their families as children and taken to commonwealth-run ­facilities will receive a one-off $75,000 payment under a $378m redress scheme to be outlined by Scott Morrison on Thursday.

    The reparations will put pressure on Western Australia and Queensland – the only states that do not have redress schemes for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people taken from their families under historic policies – to match the commitment.

    The Prime Minister, outlining the government’s response to the new national Closing the Gap agreement, will tell parliament an apology for the Stolen Generations is not enough.

    “We have already confronted it with the national apology. But our deeds must match our words,” Mr Morrison will say, ­according to an early copy of his speech obtained by The Australian. The payment, he will say, is “in recognition of the harm caused by forced removal”.

    “And it will give each survivor the opportunity, should they wish, to tell their story, and receive an individual apology.

    “This is a long-called-for step. Recognising the bond between healing, dignity, and the health and wellbeing of members of the Stolen Generations, their families and their communities.

    “To say, formally, not just that we’re deeply sorry for what happened, but that we will take responsibility for it.”

    About 3200 people in the Northern Territory and 400 in the Australian Capital Territory will qualify for the scheme.

    It is due to begin in 2022, 25 years after the Bringing Them Home report found that, under international law, from approximately 1946 the policies of forcible removal amount to genocide.

    The report concluded that between one in three and one in 10 Indigenous children were forcibly removed from their communities between 1910 and 1970.

    Mr Morrison will reveal the ­redress payments as part of the commonwealth’s $1bn response to the new national agreement on Closing the Gap, a 10-year plan to reduce Indigenous disadvantage against 17 targets.

    The new spending on Closing the Gap includes $160m on children’s health and early learning and $254m for community-controlled Aboriginal health groups.

    Those organisations impressed the government by efficiently rolling out Covid-19 vaccinations to remote communities and – in some cases – by using their rapport with residents to counter misinformation about vaccines. The money will be used to upgrade health clinics and build staff accommodation as the organisations assume a bigger role as part of Closing the Gap measures. Indigenous Australians Minister Ken Wyatt says the organisations will do critical work, and on their terms.

    The last Closing the Gap agreement is considered a failure because Australia did not meet five out of seven targets set in 2008. The new agreement differs in part because it is signed by each state and territory – as well as a coalition of 50 peak Indigenous organisations – in a commitment to work together to meet annual goals. Aboriginal community-controlled organisations will do much of the work currently done by non-Indigenous organisations and government departments.

    The government decided to go ahead with the redress scheme after discussions with The Healing Foundation, whose chief executive Fiona Cornforth had been briefed on its operation on Wednesday and described it as an important step “to end these cycles of trauma”.

    “We are so emotional about what will be announced,” Ms Cornforth said. “We have worked really hard as an organisation to elevate the voices of stolen generation survivors, their descendants and their families.

    “We know, because the data is clear now, that because of removal these survivors carry a ­burden that is significant … we welcome this and we look forward to helping to build a scheme that will do no more harm.”

    Mr Morrison will say the Closing the Gap process instigated by the Rudd government was “born of the best intentions” but “remained hard of hearing”.

    “It is why this government brought together a new 10-year (agreement), signed by all Australian governments, the Coalition of Peaks and the Australian Local Government Association,” Mr Morrison will say.

    “And from that partnership, the National Agreement on Closing the Gap was born.

    “Today, we make the promises of that agreement real with the presentation of the first commonwealth implementation plan.

    “In financial commitments, partnership, shared accountability and scope, this is the most ­significant and comprehensive response to Closing the Gap that the government has ever provided,” Mr Morrison will say.

    An annual commonwealth progress report will be tabled by the government in parliament

    Mr Morrison will say the ultimate test for the plan will be providing every Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander child “the same opportunities and expectations as any other Australian”.


    Report comment
  9. struth says:

    26 million Australians have had their livesstolen from them over the last eighteen months.
    I don’t know about you but my reparations will involve pollies to be paying more than just money.


    Report comment
  10. John Bayley says:

    Closing the Gap: Stolen children to be given $378m redress

    Well…it’s only money, and now that the RBA has fully embraced the printing press-driven path to recovery, all it takes is pressing the Ctrl+P buttons a few times and all past wrongs are miraculously set right.

    Although, now that I think of it, has anyone actually managed to answer the ‘Just Name 10’ [actually stolen] aboriginal kids challenge Andrew Bolt put up some 15 years ago?


    Report comment
  11. John Bayley says:

    By the way, does anyone know how the negotiations are going when it comes to attracting past contributors to the New Cat?

    That is, C.L., Steve Kates, Rafe, David Bidstrup, to name only a few?
    I doubt we will see Judith Sloan or Henry Ergas here any time soon, but the above would make a mighty fine start indeed.


    Report comment
  12. DrBeauGan says:

    Thanks Tom.

    Adam, what Jupes said.


    Report comment
  13. Mark A says:

    Something to think about,

    Me: Hey, how do you fall asleep so quickly at night?
    Hubby: I don’t know. I just shut off my brain and then I’m asleep.
    Me: WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU JUST SHUT OFF YOUR BRAIN?
    Hubby: I dunno.
    Me: WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU DON’T KNOW?
    Hubby: I really don’t know. I just close my eyes and stop thinking.
    Me: You don’t lie there and wonder if you forgot to do something earlier in the day?
    Hubby: No.
    Me: You don’t worry that you said something stupid?
    Hubby: What? No.
    Me: You don’t replay scenarios and assume people are mad at you?
    Hubby: No.
    Me: You don’t get the sudden urge to get your life in order?
    Hubby: Ummmmm…no.
    Me: You don’t even start making up scenarios that may or may not happen in your head? Worry about the kids? Money? How to lose 5 lbs by morning? The toilet that needs to be fixed?
    Hubby: No. I’m asleep, so I’m not wondering or worrying about anything.
    Me: Literally nothing? Just close your eyes and then that’s really it?
    Hubby: Pretty much.
    Me: I’m sorry. I’m having such a hard time understanding.
    Hubby: Is that not how it works for you?
    [two minutes of silence goes by]
    Hubby: You can’t really be mad at me for this.
    Me: Goodnight.
    Hubby: Babe…
    Me: I said goodnight sir.


    Report comment
  14. jupes says:

    About 3200 people in the Northern Territory and 400 in the Australian Capital Territory will qualify for the scheme.

    How do you qualify? Does Bruce Pascoe get a cut?


    Report comment
  15. Mark A says:

    John Bayley says:
    August 5, 2021 at 5:41 am

    By the way, does anyone know how the negotiations are going when it comes to attracting past contributors to the New Cat?

    That is, C.L., Steve Kates, Rafe, David Bidstrup, to name only a few?
    I doubt we will see Judith Sloan or Henry Ergas here any time soon, but the above would make a mighty fine start indeed.

    I don’t think any of that will happen until the blog structure is sorted and the flotsam is discarded.
    ‘———————————-
    On an other note

    Which blog is going to win out and stay long term?
    Who knows?

    One thing is sure, I do have a good memory and remember monty treating those who disagreed with him, with disdain, utter contempt and sometimes with sheer hatred.

    How some people forget and forgive so quickly, make excuses even, turning themselves into pretzels in the process of explaining why this devil is the right one, for a handful of silver, so to speak. (be accepted on his blog)

    People like him do not change, ideology got them by the curlies.
    Given his age he could have done so by now.
    Anyone can be pleasant and agreeable for a while.


    Report comment
  16. Elizabeth (Lizzie) Beare says:

    Bruce of WA. Thanks for putting the insulting and pompous DM right about my comments and critique of moderation on this site on the last Open Thread. He’s a real woman-hater that one. As opposed to Johanna, who is a 0ne-woman-only hater. Adam asked for feedback. I offered some. No biggie.

    lol, Mark A. It is nothing like that. What a fervent imagination you have.
    I fall asleep as my head hits the pillow.
    Sometimes I toss because I need to wake up for a pee. 🙂


    Report comment
  17. Elizabeth (Lizzie) Beare says:

    “By the way, does anyone know how the negotiations are going when it comes to attracting past contributors to the New Cat?

    That is, C.L., Steve Kates, Rafe, David Bidstrup, to name only a few?”

    I’d imagine they would not be enjoying the Bird strike.


    Report comment
  18. Knuckle Dragger says:

    How’s traffic on your own blog Bird? Less than stellar?

    That’s because people aren’t interested in you, or your personal one-man grievance industry.

    Admit that you are here only because there’s an audience, and that people come here for a range of competent views on a range of subjects. Admit that you can’t gain traction on your own, and only receive any visibility at all because you ride on the backs of others.

    You could have been a contender once. You turned into Lionel Rose. A damaged ex-ex something who used to turn up at every death involving any part-indig person in Fitzroy and Collingwood, and remove the deceased’s wallet and watch while claiming to be their ‘uncle’.

    In other words, a lightweight.


    Report comment
  19. Mater says:

    How some people forget and forgive so quickly, make excuses even, turning themselves into pretzels in the process of explaining why this devil is the right one, for a handful of silver, so to speak. (be accepted on his blog)

    Not me.
    A light scale reminder. Not exhaustive.

    m0nty
    #3136959, posted on August 21, 2019 at 11:07 am

    A conviction doesn’t made it true Monty.

    He is a convicted rock spider, an horrific monster and stands for everything that right-thinking people should reject. Anyone who continues to support him is on the side of evil.

    Or, perhaps if you’re in for some random, ideological violence.

    m0nty
    #2275181, posted on January 26, 2017 at 1:21 pm

    yes, it is always correct to punch Nazis. They lost the right to not be punched in the face when they started spouting genocidal ideologies that in living memory killed millions upon millions of people.

    Well said, that man.

    This site might be on the nose right now, but I’ll be damned if I’ll trade in my principles and go running into arms of Monty, just because he lashed out on some plugins.
    Plug-ins are cheap, I’m not.


    Report comment
  20. Knuckle Dragger says:

    ‘I’ll be damned if I’ll trade in my principles and go running into arms of Monty, just because he lashed out on some plugins.’

    Damn straight.

    The porky ranga will be sitting in his basement, stroking a bald cat at the very thought of former adherents of that august journal or record gravitating to his own Venus fly trap of a site.

    ‘Muahaha ha ha. Yeessssss, my pretties. Come closer. Closer.’


    Report comment
  21. Mother Lode says:

    Damn.

    Someone stepped in mushroom bullshit and have walked it in into the new carpet.


    Report comment
  22. H B Bear says:

    I don’t even like mushrooms.

    DO IT!


    Report comment
  23. Elizabeth (Lizzie) Beare says:

    M0nty would never put up with Bird on his site. That is the attraction for me.

    If Adam can address that issue, this site may yet thrive.

    For the record, many here have been far more trenchant in their stated demands for the removal of Bird and his anti-Semitism than I have been. And good on them. I have kept it polite, and requested not demanded. Yes, I have been upset about it for Cassie’s sake, definitely: Cassie is a personal friend of mine. Yet I am called ‘a tyrant’ by DM as well as receiving the usual insulting and classic bullshit from Johanna and the likes of K2.

    What pathetic frauds they are. I wonder what other shadows they jump at.

    Now, as I often do when ole Ma Nature gets me up early, I am going back to bed.


    Report comment
  24. Carpe Jugulum says:

    Good Morning All

    I’ll get the Karcher out and clean up the bird poo.

    Good toons and lame pics today


    Report comment
  25. Elizabeth (Lizzie) Beare says:

    “In other words, a lightweight.”

    —-

    Now, now, KD, don’t filch Hairy’s word for Johanna.

    Poor old Bird has no weight at all. He is a sad very mentally ill man.
    I hope he is banned from here. It would be for his own good too.
    He might seek some appropriate help for his mental high before he crashes into a further depression.


    Report comment
  26. Top Ender says:

    THE Central Land Council (CLC) is offering all its employees, the majority of whom are Indigenous, a cash incentive of $500 to get the Covid-19 jab.

    It’s believed to be the first NT business or organisation to offer a financial payment to get vaccinated against the coronavirus.

    CLC chief executive Lesley Turner said the organisation began offering the incentive due to a lack of government awareness campaigns targeted at Aboriginal people.

    “We had to do something before it’s too late and we get community transmission of the highly infectious Delta strain here in the Territory,” he said. “We wanted to encourage a higher uptake of vaccinations in our remote communities because our Aboriginal health services tell us the vaccine uptake has been very patchy.”

    Mr Turner said when the cash campaign kicked off five weeks ago, just two per cent of his 200 employees were vaccinated.

    He said that figure has now spiked to almost 100 employees, which includes elected Aboriginal councillors and executive members.

    NT News


    Report comment
  27. Bruce of Newcastle says:

    This one is for the Premiers and their white coat experts. And for ScoMo.

    Double-Blind Ivermectin Study Reveals COVID Patients Recover More Quickly, Are Less Infectious (4 Aug)

    A double-blind Israeli study has concluded that Ivermectin, an inexpensive anti-parasitic widely used since 1981, reduces both the duration and infectiousness of Covid-19, according to the Jerusalem Post.
    …
    “Our study shows first and foremost that ivermectin has antiviral activity,” said Schwartz, adding “It also shows that there is almost a 100% chance that a person will be noninfectious in four to six days, which could lead to shortening isolation time for these people. This could have a huge economic and social impact.”

    The study, which appeared on the MedRxiv preprint server and has not yet been peer-reviewed. That said, Schwartz pointed out that similar studies – ‘though not all of them conducted to the same double-blind and placebo standards as his’ – also showed favorable results for the drug.

    The stuff really does appear to be on a par with the vaccines in terms of effectiveness, and much more easy to get, cheaper and no special cold storage required.

    Over to you Australian governments. You say you believe the science? Well you don’t get better than a well designed double-blind study.


    Report comment
  28. 132andBush says:

    What Mark A and Mater said.

    Monty’s veil is as thin as wet toilet paper and he regularly let it slip.


    Report comment
  29. Bons says:

    Ramirez”s artwork is amazing. He must devote a lot of time each day to producing his toons, even with a drawing program.


    Report comment
  30. Mater says:

    M0nty would never put up with Bird on his site. That is the attraction for me.

    That is undoubtedly true, Lizzie.
    Which leads to the obvious question, what else will he not put up with once (if) he kills off all the competition?

    No one who supported the lockdowns, and still supports them, has enough understanding and respect for freedom and individuality to run a site that was the Cat. Sorry.


    Report comment
  31. Vicki says:

    Daily Mail reporting that family of young man who died in lockdown apparently with covid, had a heart condition. All family names reported. They further reported that heart conditions common in their family.

    ABC, on the contrary, reporting that family say he was perfectly healthy.


    Report comment
  32. Knuckle Dragger says:

    ‘I had to shut down my second blog because of harassment.’

    Because nobody was interested in it, you mean. Then you had to use the credibility of others to briefly screech in the sun before being returned to irrelevance, instead of using your own two feet.

    You blame your own inadequacies on centuries – nay, millennia – of imagined slights from people you don’t know, who don’t know about you and wouldn’t care if they did.

    As with so many in this day and age, Bird, it’s always someone else fault. Isn’t it?


    Report comment
  33. Knuckle Dragger says:

    *else’s*

    Where are my smokes?


    Report comment
  34. Adam D Adam D says:

    I have smited my first smite in the form of Bird whom broke the no d***head policy. Whilst I didn’t agree with his views it was not so much what they were but the way they were expressed that ultimately cost his fate.

    If anyone disagrees let me know as I formulate a moderating policy. Also 2 things to note

    1. His post are gone so some of your replies may look out of place, apologies for that

    2. He will likely be back so vigilance will be key, just let me know via email for faster avian control


    Report comment
  35. Elizabeth (Lizzie) Beare says:

    Re the new Ivermectin study, I’d be interested to know the vax status of the participants. Unless controlled for, it could be a confounding factor. I would expect they have it covered, but you can’t tell from the summary.

    Re M0nty – he starts with the assumption a good site would need moderation, and Bird is the classic exemplar of that. He says his moderation would follow that of Sinc. I suspect he would stick by that. Adam says he is addressing the issue of how to moderate. We shall have to see how that turns out.

    I am no tyrant. Nor would I want to be involved in doing any moderation.
    Basically, I am too soft-hearted for it. 🙂


    Report comment
  36. Eyrie says:

    Lizzie, if you don’t like this site, just go over to Monty’s tender loving arms and stop posting here.


    Report comment
  37. Top Ender says:

    Education Minister Alan Tudge has slammed a Brisbane school which set students a task to describe why we should change the Australian flag.

    James Morrow
    DAILY TELEGRAPH

    While Aussie athletes go for gold in Tokyo, Australian students are being taught to denigrate the flag and anthem they are competing under, according to federal Education Minister Alan Tudge.

    Pointing to a civics and citizenship class assignment for Year 7 students given out at high school in Brisbane’s northern suburbs, Mr Tudge said it was a clear example of how some in the education ­establishment are trying to “undermine our country, its symbols and institutions”.

    The exercise calls for students to “complete a three-minute speech to the Youth Parliament on why we need to change the Australian anthem or flag to reflect the values and identity of Australian society today”.

    “In the middle of the Olympics, where the country is singing the anthem and waving our flag, this is what the school sets?” Mr Tudge asked.

    “It doesn’t even give students the opportunity to take their own position. Rather, they have to say why the flag no longer reflects us.

    “Mainstream Australia is sick to death of those elements in the education system trying to undermine our country, its symbols and institutions.”

    Mr Tudge pointed to the ­assignment as an example of why students are doing so poorly in civics and citizenship education.

    Earlier this year, tests revealed that just 38 per cent of Year 10 students and 53 per cent of Year 6s were able to achieve a “proficient” standard in civics and citizenship, ­reflecting a continuing slide in their understanding of the workings of Australian democracy that has been occurring for at least a decade.

    Currently, the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) is taking feedback on a draft revised curriculum in all subject areas.


    Report comment
  38. Dot says:

    Bruce

    Idiots like “Matt” will bitch, moan and caterwaul that it hasn’t been peer reviewed yet and they will make up stuff about randomisation and controls. Pure whatabouttism.

    “Well ackchually, said the bugman…”

    No, you haven’t read the paper. You have it a quick hit with Ctrl F.


    Report comment