This video has been put together by the Center for Humane Technology – a non-profit working to align technology with humanity’s best interests. They encourage viewers to consider calling their political representatives to advocate for holding hearings on Artificial Intelligence (AI) risk and creating adequate guardrails.
About the video:
Tristan Harris and Aza Raskin discuss how existing AI capabilities already pose catastrophic risks to a functional society, how AI companies are caught in a race to deploy as quickly as possible without adequate safety measures, and what it would mean to upgrade our institutions to a post-AI world.
This presentation is from a private gathering in San Francisco on March 9th, 2023 with leading technologists and decision-makers with the ability to influence the future of large-language model AIs. This presentation was given before the launch of GPT-4.
The AI Dilemma
The law of unintended consequences strikes again
Report comment
As can be seen in the video, it is clear that Tristan Harris and Aza Raskin have done a great deal of research on the subject. There are major risks to our society if AI is allowed to proceed unchecked.
Tristan Harris says:
As the ladder gets taller……these are dangerous concerns and they undermine all of the other benefits.
Report comment
Is Artificial Intelligence Dangerous?
6 AI Risks Everyone Should Know About
Report comment
How Smart is ChatGPT?
ChatGPT 3.5 vs ChatGPT 4.0
Report comment
We know who the people behind ultra-modern technologies are and they aren’t good guys so, to me, it’s a moot point. Most people are stuck in the very bad habit of googling for something and not going past page 1. It’s been around for years anyway. It might get better but better isn’t necessarily better. All modern cars have lots of AI.
Report comment
Duckduckgo.com is now searching for itself instead of just recycling the results of the other search engines behind a curtain.
I generally use DDG by default but will use the big G when the balance of quality results trumps my desire for privacy. I can live with G knowing my preferred sneaker brand. (Not the KT-26 these days.)
Report comment
Wall Street Journal
Report comment
Yep, we tend to forget that the world actually worked quite well without computers. So perhaps the ‘unintended consequence’ of AI is the self destruction of the digital realm.
OMG!!!!!
Those two boys sound like a mixture of Mormons and preschool teachers. The coming Apocalypse, climate change, A.I….. no no no more disasters.
Report comment
It may not be the perfect search engine but Startpage feeds off from the Google database but claims to provide privacy, too.
Keeping ourselves completely free from being tracked would not be possible. We depend on BigTech to deal with our everyday lives. But we can limit how much access we allow them. We also need to be aware of the tricks they are up to.
Report comment
JohnJJJ, I was wondering why you hadn’t responded to this topic.
I know you mentioned the wonders of ChatGPT to us here, months ago. So I was hoping you would add your experiences about the risks of AI and tools like ChatGPT.
I think I may be able to take a correct guess on whether or not you agree with Tristan and Aza. 🙂
Report comment
I think I may be able to take a correct guess on whether or not you agree with Tristan and Aza. 🙂
It’s not that I disagree, I just don’t understand why they take so long to say there may be unintended results of relying on A.I. Everyone I met has used “A.I. fear” as an excuse to protect their job with faux moral concern. What are the morals of these two clowns?
Here are a few annoying stories. One academic said to me that ChatGPT is wrong on some facts that he knew. My reply was you get things wrong as well, however ChatGPT learned from you, what did you learn? The second is the college telling students that ChatGPT can be detected. It can’t. They are trying to scare the students. If it was “detected”, it would learn and improve. People just don’t get it and hence use the uncertainty, like climate gobbledygook, as a ‘concern’ power trip.
As to the risks, I don’t know. Morality is the guide to navigate uncertainty. But, thanks for asking.
Report comment
But we can limit how much access we allow them. We also need to be aware of the tricks they are up to
You are right, every single action in the digital world can be tracked. So if you don’t want that, you need to be confusing. Then the time taken to track you is not worth it compared to the ROI. Tracking uses linkages. It looks for links between accounts then creates a table of the links. For example if you use the Google account to register with any other website, all the tracking needs is your Google info. So, be confusing and not worth the effort. Like these guys Four Lions – Anti Surveillance
Report comment
They provide examples of their research. For example, they pretend to be a young girl going out on a date with an older man and the data they provide to the AI bot suggests grooming, but the AI responds with encouraging this girl rather than sounding the alarm.
How will the use of AI affect gullible young people? And that is just one of the unknowns.
Tristan is battling on the topic at government levels.
Tristan Harris Congress Testimony:
Understanding the Use of Persuasive Technology
Report comment
Pause Giant AI Experiments:
An Open Letter
Report comment
should be planned for and managed with commensurate care and resources. Thanks for keeping the discussion going.
Looks like a majority of scientist agree. But they are yelling at the clouds. The Golem has been created. It is this scene
Report comment
Here is the situation to be sung to the melody of Greensleeves:
In a world of sound and fury, untold,
Where power plays, a crisis tale unfolds,
Intelligent engineers, they conspire,
In shadows they dance, their secret’s A.I.
(Chorus)
Oh, the drama, it runs so deep,
Amidst the concerns that make us weep,
Marketing, investors, academics, they vie,
For a position of power, where they won’t die.
Ambition gleams bright in their hungry eyes,
Seeking an edge, where their power lies,
A web of intrigue, they jockey and fight,
Guarding themselves from a Neural Network blight.
(Chorus)
(Bridge)
Now the test awaits, a moment profound,
Catallay-files.com, its fate is tightly wound,
Will the impact be great, or a gentle breeze?
In this revelation, do we find unease?
(Chorus)
The stage is set, the tension grows,
In this digital tale, as the story unfolds,
With rhyming verses, the plot takes hold,
So,embrace the chaos, as the secrets are told.
(Chorus)
(Outro)
In this song of intrigue, the journey’s complete,
The drama unfurled, as the world takes its seat,
With Greensleeves as our guide, we sing the tale,
Of power and grifting, where secrets prevail.
Report comment
Keeping it going ….🤨
It’s artificial but not intelligent.
Apple’s New ‘Mixed-Reality’ Headset
Is Designed To Isolate And Control You
Report comment
One World Religion
WEF Calls for AI to Rewrite Bible,
Create ‘Religions That Are Actually Correct’
In response, Archbishop Viganò says:
Report comment
I note he is not suggesting re-writing the Koran.
Report comment
I note he is not suggesting re-writing the Koran
This explains the modern world in one sentence.
Report comment
Just a thought as we watch the West dissolve through lack of strength and leadership. Obviously this is due to the rise of feminine thinking into positions of power i.e. all the characteristics of nesting: caring, equity and lying needed to raise children.
So where have the smart men gone? My thinking is into IT. I’ve been reading up on topics such as semantic networks, zero knowledge proof, polynomial time and the like. This is heavy duty thinking and it has nothing to do (directly) with ethics, governing or society. So what would have been the current and future leaders are now corralled into the digital world in a fantasy land.
Report comment
The lines are getting blurred between reality and fantasy. Geoffrey Hinton, the “godfather of AI” has been warning about AI’s risks.
AI: The worst-case scenario
Report comment
There is a line in an Isaac Asimov short story about a super-intelligent computer asked “Is there a god?”
The answer was “There is now”
Report comment